Jameson – intertextuality in music

Standard

”Nothing is original. Steal from anywhere that resonates with inspiration or fuels your imagination…. And don’t bother concealing your thievery – celebrate it if you feel like it,” says film director Jim Jarmusch. Although Jarmusch was talking about films, he could easily have been talking about the fuzzy, overlapping barriers that define intertextuality in music.

Intertextuality refers to the interconnection that occurs naturally or purposefully in works of art. Because no art is created in a vacuum, it is natural for writers, filmmakers, musicians, and other artists to include references to other people’s art in their own art. It helps them create connections with their audience or to illustrate a larger point they are trying to make by creating a parallel to other art their audience is already familiar with. Sometimes intertextuality slips in without the creator directly noticing.

An allusion is a brief and sometimes indirect reference to another work of art and a very common form of deliberate intertextuality. For example, in the opening lines of his classic hip hop song ”Gangsta’s Paradise,” Coolio raps, ”As I walk through the valley of the shadow of death,”. The line is a reference to Psalm 23 in the Bible. ”Gangsta’s Paradise” doesn’t go on to explain this reference. It just leaves it there for listeners to understand or not. However, catching the reference can add a little depth to one’s understanding of the lyrics.

Covers: paying homage to another’s skill and expertise.  A compilation of hit covers.

The Subtle Nod: could be as little as a quotation from some one else’s lyrics.

Collabs:  singers work together – a bricolage of styles and music genres.

Sampling:  and can include the mash-up (bricolage) and also quotatation – a direct lift!  It can bring together fans from all different genres to one song. SOS by Rihanna samples Tainted Love by Soft Cell for example.  All you Need is Love by the Beatles includes the French National Anthem!  The Mash Up: Jive Bunny is the best.

Rip-offs: Latest example Ed Sheerhan and Thinking Out Loud and Marvin Gaye’s, Let’s Get it On.

Songs within songs:  Actually using someone’s else song within yours: Ariana Grande, 7 Rings   and These are a few of my Favourite things – The Sound of Music. David Guetta featuring Bebe Rexha – “Blue (I’m Good)” (2017, built on the melody from Eiffel 65’s “I’m Blue” from 1999). Portugal. The Man – “Feel It Still (2017, the chorus is based on the melody to The Marvelettes’ 1961 hit “Please Mr. Postman“). The Byrds – “She Don’t Care About Time (1965, quotes Bach’s “Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring” at 1:16). Melanie Martinez – “Pity Party” (2015, based on Lesley Gore’s 1963 hit “It’s My Party“)

This song is packed full of references to songs from the ‘noughties’. Watch it first and then read the article to see if you can identify the songs – the intertextual references.

 

Jameson – intertextuality in Music Videos

Standard

Music Videos are often examples of postmodern media, not only because their place as a recognised art form has come about in the postmodern era but mainly because they evidence a range of ideas about what makes a text postmodern.

Intertextuality

  • Pastiche – use of a previous text as the basis for the whole music video – in the style of
  • Parody – making fun of a previous text
  • Homage and Quotation – sampling
  • Weaponised intertextuality – those deliberate Easter Eggs – we will look more closely at Ariana Grande and This is America as a detailed texts later in the term.

Bricolage – a melange, mixture of styles – cartoons, animations, dance, drama, acting, documentary, other footage.

Self-referential – this is a music video (think of Katy Perry winking at the end of xxx) – let’s draw attention to its own construction.

They manipulate time and space – flashbacks, incomplete narratives usually present and they often challenge the grand narratives (more on this later) – there is not always a happy ending, a dominant male, success after working hard for a living.

Play with the relationship between audience and text – breaking the 4th wall and there is often a presumption they are culturally competent, deliberately playing with their expectations.

Play with the distinction between reality and representation.

They blur the lines between high art and what is considered low art.

Examples:

See how many intertextual references you can see in this Taylor Swift video.

Poppy is a social media phenomena who not only makes her own fascinating blog posts but also sings and creates music videos. This one is particularly self-referential and deliberately questions the music industry.

The 1975 are a really interesting band. The approach their music with a wry sense of intellectual cyncism and often end up evidencing postmodern trends in their work.  Here is Matty Healy talking us through his music videos.

Here is one example in full.

This music video is self-reflexive.  Draws attention to itself in a shameless way.  Pokes a finger up at celebrity culture – he ‘ribs’ himself about his celebrity lifestyle.  Read this Article for more background.

And this is what happened at the Brits in 2017. Not strictly a music video but it evidences a self-referential nod towards the music industry.
This is a little old now but it shows a self-referentiality (this is a music video that we have constructed) but it also points the finger at a wider postmodern scope i.e. the idea that people are lost in their hypereal worlds, unaware of their real lives and surroundings.  We will look more at this later.

Top 10 Music Videos inspired by Movies: they are all examples of how music videos pastiche, parody previous texts. Again, you have to be culturally competent to ‘get it’ but you could also argue it is singers being lazy and unimaginative – why not just copy someone else’s art?

Andrew Goodwin, a renowned media theorist sums up the postmodernism of music videos:

  1.  Blurs high art and low art – it is media for everyone with no boundaries.
  2.  Abandons/challenges grand narratives – incomplete narratives, no sense of resolution, rejection of the overarching ideologies of society/history – love conquers all, men are the breadwinners, god is the answer etc.
  3. Intertextuality – borrows from other texts; deliberately, unknowingly, alludes to, knowing nod to – all of which fits with Jameson’s ideas on ‘nothing new, a flatness’ or as he puts it ‘blank parody’.
  4. Loss of Historical reality – pastiche and intertextuality blur history and chronology so that conventional notions of past, present and future  are lost in a melange of images, all of which appear to be contemporary.

 

 

 

Postmodernism in a nutshell

Standard

Don’t be frightened about the term ‘postmodern’.  If the context confuses you i.e. what went before that is not overly important. In fact why not just approach the topic as this is us looking at the media that surrounds us at the moment and we are looking at various criteria that can be used to analyse, critique and review it.

Postmodern is a term used to describe much of contemporary media that surrounds us today! SIMPLES – and is can be analysed, critiqued in reference to various ideas, theories, terms etc.

Here are the key ideas that encapsulate what postmodernism is all about:-

Postmodernism:

  • is a movement from the late 20th century
  • represents a departure from modernism
  • challenges authority
  • rejects the idea of status/ value
  • makes fun of existing texts – parody/satire
  • is a critique of what we assume to be real
  • copies ideas/styles from existing texts
  • suggests there is no absolute ‘truth’ – merely socially constructed truths
  • gives a skeptical interpretation
  • is a reinterpretation of classical ideas, forms and practices
  • questions our perception of art
  • distrusts dominant ideologies
  • mixes styles
  • plays with reality
  • challenges ‘fixed’ ideologies
  • challenges the rebellion of modernism
  • it is playful
  • blurs reality and representation
  • it looks to the past
  • is really hard to define

to name just a few things…

Some key terms that we will consider over the coming weeks – pastiche, parody, quotation, intertextuality, loss of historical reality, cultural competence, hyper reality, simulacra, consumer culture, hegemony, grand narratives.

Postmodern Media – Moving on – what on earth is this?

Standard

POMO – Moving on – WHAT IS POSTMODERNISM?

postm

The coursework is over. ‘The Blog is dead. Long live the Blog!‘ (this, by the way, is an intertextual reference with a hint of parody, so could be classed as an example of postmodern literacy BUT OF COURSE you have to be culturally competent to get it!!)

But what the heck is Postmodernism?

Baudrillard was a cool French guy

Who constantly makes media students cry

Hyperreality is now a real thing

You can get paid even if you can’t sing

So set your sights high

For a media ride you should try

Postmodernism is the thing……postmodernism is King!

Does any of this make sense? The above is a Limerick penned by an A2 student, that in 5 short weeks will make complete and utter sense.

By Easter, you will be ready and armed with textual references and theorists galore so that you can answer Section 2 of the Component 4 paper. The essay is worth 50 marks and should take about an hour to write in the exam. So it is an extremely important part of your A Level course.

Heads down…..brains engage.

Off we goooo….

A postmodern joke – get it? No…?

postmodernism

This is a slide show which tries to explain a definition of Postmodernism:

Still stuck? Here are some video explanations:

TASK – POSTMODERN TERMS

How would you define Postmodernism in 20 words? If you can do it, you are a super scholar!  Even university professors seem to struggle to agree, but it would be good to have a go. Read the following to see if it helps.

You can also use these to help with the allocated Postmodern term exercise on classroom.